MembersHelpJoinRecent discussionsPress CoverageAdvertising

Interact Inn Home


    Recent Discussions   


MTNL vs. VSNL

14th March 1999      Aniruddh Binani @bigfoot.com

How Good is MTNl as an isp ????
How wud it  rate..
in comparrison to vsnl ..


14th March 1999      Kejriwal @giasbma.vsnl.net.in

I am a subscribe or MTNL, and frankly am not at all satisfied. I
have had a problem sending mails and have called up their
helpdesk several times in the past weeek, but to no effect yet.

Further, it has operations only in Mumbai and Delhi. Soif you're
in some other town, you cannot log in.

To top it all, VSNL now offers 80% discount on renewals. Which
means you just pay 500 more than MTNL, and that too only once,
for a countrywide access, cheaper renewals (2400/- vs. 2500/-
for 100hrs), shell login, and a great helpdesk.

AS per my experience with both the ISPs, VSNL wins hands down.

Hemant


15th March 1999      Arup A. Bhanja @cal.vsnl.net.in

Hi Hemant,

You wrote:
[snip]
>To top it all, VSNL now offers 80% discount on renewals.

80% discount???? That makes it Rs. 2,400 (80% of 3,000) off so it would be
Rs. 600 to renew 100 hrs.????

>Which
>means you just pay 500 more than MTNL, and that too only once,
>for a countrywide access, cheaper renewals (2400/- vs. 2500/-
>for 100hrs), shell login, and a great helpdesk.

Please, can you explain the math here?

regards,
Arup


16th March 1999      Sumeet Shroff @bom3.vsnl.net.in

> I am a subscribe or MTNL, and frankly am not at all satisfied. I
> have had a problem sending mails and have called up their
> helpdesk several times in the past weeek, but to no effect yet.

mtnl is setting up a task force to upgrade quality. - news courtesy
Express Computers.

> 
> Further, it has operations only in Mumbai and Delhi. Soif you're
> in some other town, you cannot log in.

they will take time to set up operation elsewhere.

> To top it all, VSNL now offers 80% discount on renewals. Which

20% discount.

> for 100hrs), shell login, and a great helpdesk.

a *great helpdesk* ????   hehehe....

> AS per my experience with both the ISPs, VSNL wins hands down.

u r, with no hard feeling, comparing an infant to young man. wait till
there are more isp floating around who have to offer so many services
which we havn't still heard off, and then make a better and helpful
judgement.


16th March 1999      Krishnan J iyer @bcmfax.net

>> Andhon Mein Kaana Raja << What do you mean by this? 


18th March 1999      Vani Murarka @manaskriti.com

This is a saying in Hindi - a muhawara. Kaana means a person who has 
one eye. Hence, the saying means, that in a land of blind man, if one 
has even one eye, one will be king. Or the better (but still not a good 
one) choice amongst lousy ones.

Vani


_____________________________________________________________
 Vani Murarka                          
 Manaskriti Software Solutions     http://www.manaskriti.com
 Calcutta, India                 Ph: 91-33-4746625 / 4754838

            - Customised Software Development -
          - Website Development, Web Programming -
       - Lyris List Hosting, Reselling & Consultancy -
_____________________________________________________________

Top